1. Finance Commission of India
The Finance Commission of India is a crucial institution in the country's federal structure. Established under Article 280 of the Indian Constitution, the Finance Commission is tasked with making recommendations on the distribution of tax revenue between the central government and the individual state governments. It also addresses the principles governing grants-in-aid provided by the central government to states. As of April 2024, India is awaiting the constitution of the Sixteenth Finance Commission. The Fifteenth Finance Commission's recommendations cover the period up to March 2026.
Composition
- The President of India appoints the Finance Commission every five years or earlier.
- Parliament can define the qualifications for membership and the selection process.
- The Commission typically comprises a chairperson (usually a judge or an economist) and other members with expertise in relevant fields.
Functions
- Recommend the sharing ratio of net proceeds of certain taxes (like income tax, and customs duty) between the central government and the states.
- Determine the principles governing grants-in-aid to states from the Consolidated Fund of India. These grants are meant to assist states with limited resources or for specific purposes like social welfare programs.
- Consider any other matter referred to it by the President in the interest of sound finance.
Significance
- The Finance Commission plays a vital role in ensuring equitable distribution of financial resources between the central government and states.
- This promotes balanced development across India by providing additional support to states with greater financial needs.
- The Commission's recommendations are not binding, but they hold significant weight and are usually accepted by the government.
Criticisms and Challenges
- Some states argue that the current formula for distributing tax revenue doesn't adequately address their specific needs and development challenges.
- There are ongoing debates about the weightage given to different factors (like population, and income disparity) in the distribution formula.
Public finance is the branch of economics that examines the role of government in the economy, specifically focusing on how governments manage their revenue, spending, and debt. It's essentially about how governments pay for the things they do and how they raise that money.
Components
- Revenue includes all the income sources for the government. Taxes (income tax, sales tax, etc.) are the major source, but other revenue streams include user fees, charges for government services, and income generated from government assets.
- Expenditure refers to how the government spends its revenue. These expenditures cover a wide range of areas like public services (education, healthcare, infrastructure), social programs (welfare benefits, pensions), national defence, and debt servicing (paying interest on borrowed money).
- When a government spends more than it collects in revenue, it runs a budget deficit. To finance this deficit, governments often borrow money by issuing bonds. The total amount of money borrowed by the government is its public debt.
Key Objectives
- Public finance aims to ensure the efficient allocation of resources within the economy. The government uses its spending to provide essential public goods and services that the private sector might not deliver efficiently.
- Public finance can be used to achieve a fairer distribution of income in society. Taxes can be structured progressively (taking a higher percentage from those with higher incomes) and used to fund social programs that benefit lower-income groups.
- The government's fiscal policy (taxation and spending decisions) can be used to influence economic activity. By increasing or decreasing spending or adjusting tax rates, the government can try to stimulate economic growth during recessions or curb inflation during economic booms.
Importance of Public Finance
- Public finance ensures the government can provide essential services like national defence, law enforcement, and public infrastructure, which are crucial for a well-functioning society.
- Public programs funded through taxes can help address social issues like poverty, inequality, and unemployment.
- The government's fiscal policy plays a vital role in maintaining economic stability by promoting growth and managing inflation.
Challenges in Public Finance
- Governments face the constant challenge of balancing competing demands for resources. They need to allocate funds for various needs while ensuring fiscal responsibility and avoiding excessive debt.
- The design of the tax system can impact income inequality. Striking a balance between raising sufficient revenue and ensuring fairness in the tax burden is crucial.
- Rising public debt can be a concern for long-term economic stability. Governments need to manage their spending and borrowing responsibly to ensure future generations aren't burdened by excessive debt.
3. Public Debt and Fiscal Management in India
The issue of public debt and fiscal management is gaining significant attention within Centre-State financial relations, especially following the establishment of the Sixteenth Union Finance Commission. There is a growing consensus that the dynamics of debt and deficits are pivotal in shaping the economic landscape of India.
Post-COVID-19 Fiscal Strategy and Debt Dynamics
- In the post-COVID-19 pandemic fiscal strategy, states are expected to maintain a fiscal deficit to GDP ratio of 3.5%, with 0.5% linked to power sector reforms.
- Additionally, the target for general government public debt to GDP stands at 60%, with central government debt capped at 40%.
- For instance, Kerala's outstanding liabilities are at 36.9% of the Gross State Domestic Product (GSDP) as per the 2024-25 Budget Estimates (BE).
- Despite this, Kerala faces minimal rollover risk due to its manageable debt maturity profile, with around 16% of debt set to mature within 2025.
- On the other hand, Telangana enjoys a longer-term debt maturity profile, with a significant portion of debt refinancing scheduled for as late as 2063, contrasting with Kerala's 14.7% by comparison.
Revenue Stability and Expenditure Design
- Revenue stability forms the cornerstone of public expenditure design. In Kerala, own tax revenue constitutes a substantial 48% of total revenue, with additional revenue streams like own non-tax revenue (including lotteries) contributing around 12%.
- Recent data from the Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) shed light on fiscal projections versus actuals, as of November 2023.
- Kerala's fiscal marksmanship ratio for tax revenue stands at 57.23%, indicating a modest alignment between budget estimates and actuals.
- Notably, the fiscal marksmanship of Goods and Services Tax (GST) this fiscal year is showing improvement, with a ratio of 56.30% compared to the previous year's 54.21%, as per the CAG report.
- These metrics underscore the ongoing efforts and challenges in maintaining fiscal discipline and revenue accuracy in the Indian fiscal landscape.
Kerala has challenged the central government's decision regarding the net borrowing limit imposed on states. This dispute highlights the complexities of Centre-State financial relations in India.
Kerala's Argument
- The state argues that the Centre's imposition of a net borrowing ceiling restricts its ability to borrow funds for essential development projects.
- Kerala believes it has a manageable debt profile, with a lower debt-to-GDP ratio compared to other states.
- They claim the current formula for setting borrowing limits doesn't consider their specific needs and development challenges.
Centre's Justification
- The central government argues that imposing borrowing limits is necessary to ensure fiscal discipline among states and prevent excessive debt accumulation.
- They believe a national approach to managing public debt is crucial for India's overall economic stability.
Key Issues
- Equity vs. Efficiency: The current system might not adequately address the needs of growing states like Kerala, which face challenges despite showing economic progress.
- Intergovernmental Transfers: The volatility and formula for central government transfers raise concerns about fairness in resource allocation.
- Debt Management: Balancing the need for borrowing for development with responsible debt management practices is crucial.
Possible Solutions
- The Sixteenth Finance Commission could consider revising the formula to better reflect factors like a state's debt maturity profile and development needs.
- States may seek greater autonomy in managing their finances, potentially with revised borrowing limits or increased control over resource allocation.
- Improved communication and collaboration between the Centre and states are essential for finding a sustainable solution.
National Impact
This dispute has broader implications for India's fiscal landscape. It raises questions about the balance of power between the Centre and states, the effectiveness of intergovernmental transfers, and the overall approach to public debt management.
5. Navigating Volatility in Intergovernmental Fiscal Transfers
The Kerala government has highlighted concerns regarding the volatility in intergovernmental fiscal transfers, particularly noting a decline in the share of Union Finance Commission tax transfers for several states, including Kerala. This trend is evident when examining the inter se State share of Kerala in Finance Commission transfers, which decreased from 2.341% in the Thirteenth Finance Commission to 1.925% in the Fifteenth Finance Commission, despite a temporary increase to 2.5% in the Fourteenth Finance Commission.
Factors Influencing Tax Transfer Formula
The Fifteenth Finance Commission's tax-transfer formula is structured around various parameters, with weightage given to population, area, income distance, demographic transition, forest and ecology, and tax effort. Notably, the emphasis on income distance in the tax-transfer formula has raised concerns, especially for states like Kerala that experience economic growth but face challenges due to the per capita income criterion.
Balancing Equity and Efficiency
This scenario sparks a debate on balancing equity and efficiency principles in intergovernmental fiscal transfers. While economic convergence is a priority for Union Finance Commissions, the current emphasis on income distance criteria poses challenges for growing states like Kerala.
Addressing Volatility through Digital Infrastructure
To mitigate volatility and enhance fiscal stability, there's a growing emphasis on increasing tax efforts by strengthening digital infrastructure in public finance. This digital transformation not only aids in better revenue collection but also facilitates efficient resource allocation.
Importance of Fiscal Policy in Economic Stability
During times of crisis, such as supply chain disruptions or energy price volatility leading to food inflation, fiscal policy plays a crucial role in maintaining economic stability. Continuity in food security measures and strategic fiscal interventions, as demonstrated by the Kerala government's initiatives to address inflation in recent budgets, are essential elements in navigating economic challenges effectively.
As Kerala navigates towards sustainable economic development, investments in a green, resilient, and knowledge-based economy emerge as imperative pillars. Establishing a "State adaptation communication" with corresponding budget allocations becomes essential to address climate-related challenges effectively.
Strategic Negotiations with Finance Commission
Ensuring progressive fiscal transfers from the Union Finance Commission demands strategic negotiations regarding the magnitude and criteria, including weightage decisions. Proactively engaging with the Sixteenth Finance Commission for specific-purpose transfers tailored to address State-specific issues such as demographic transition, migration dynamics, and climate change crisis is pivotal.
Advancing Gender Budgeting for Inclusive Growth
Prioritizing fiscal transfers based on advancements in gender budgeting, particularly in bolstering the care economy infrastructure, is critical to addressing gender disparities. This focus not only redresses inequalities but also fosters economic growth by enhancing women's labour force participation. Recognizing the inverse relationship between gender budgeting and gender inequalities underscores the State's positive role in fostering gender-aware human capital formation.
Ensuring Budget Credibility and Fiscal Marksmanship
Maintaining budget credibility, especially preceding the election cycle, is paramount to upholding public trust. Emphasizing fiscal marksmanship is crucial to align actual expenditures with budget estimates, bolstering transparency and accountability in fiscal management.
Balancing Fiscal Priorities
In the current economic landscape, fiscal austerity measures through expenditure compression are not viable options for the State. Such measures risk compromising human capital formation and impeding sustained economic growth recovery. Instead, a balanced approach that prioritizes sustainable investments while maintaining fiscal prudence is warranted for Kerala's economic resilience and prosperity.
|
Mains Pratice Questions
1. Discuss the role and significance of the Finance Commission of India in the context of Centre-State financial relations. Highlight the key functions of the Finance Commission and its impact on fiscal distribution between the central government and states. (250 Words)
2. Explain the concept of public finance and its key components. Discuss the objectives of public finance and how it influences economic activity and resource allocation in the economy. (250 Words)
3. Analyze the challenges and importance of public debt and fiscal management in India, especially in the post-COVID-19 scenario. Discuss the strategies and targets outlined for fiscal management and debt dynamics, considering the recommendations of the Fifteenth Finance Commission. (250 Words)
4. What is the concept of "gender budgeting." Explain the rationale behind gender budgeting and discuss its potential benefits for fostering inclusive growth in India. (250 words)
5. What are the key challenges faced by Indian states in achieving fiscal marksmanship (aligning revenue projections with actuals)? How can digitalization contribute to improving fiscal discipline and resource allocation in public finance? (250 words)
|
