UPSC Editorial

Back

General Studies 2 >> Governance

EDITORIAL ANALYSIS: Children, a key yet missed demographic in AI regulation

Children, a key yet missed demographic in AI regulation

 
Source: The Hindu
 
For Prelims: Artificial Intelligence (AI), Global South, Cybersecurity
For Mains: Global Partnership on Artificial Intelligence (GPAI), Digital India Act (DIA)
 
Highlights of the Article
UNICEF's guidance for policymakers on AI and children
Governance on Artificial Intelligence
Challenges in the governance of Artificial Intelligence
Un Convention on the Rights of the child
 
Context
India is to host the first-ever global summit on Artificial Intelligence (AI) this October. Additionally, as the Chair of the Global Partnership on Artificial Intelligence (GPAI), India will also be hosting the GPAI global summit in December
 
UPSC EXAM NOTES ANALYSIS:
 
1. Governance on Artificial Intelligence
Governance on Artificial Intelligence (AI) refers to the development and implementation of policies, regulations, standards, and ethical guidelines to ensure that AI technologies are developed, deployed, and used in a responsible, safe, and beneficial manner. AI governance is essential to address the ethical, legal, social, and economic challenges associated with AI and to harness its potential for the benefit of society

Here are key aspects of governance on AI:

  1. Regulatory Frameworks: Governments and regulatory bodies are responsible for creating and enforcing laws and regulations related to AI. These frameworks may cover areas such as data privacy, algorithmic accountability, safety, and liability. For example, the European Union's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) includes provisions related to automated decision-making.

  2. Ethical Guidelines: Ethical principles and guidelines for AI development and deployment are crucial. Organizations and institutions often develop AI ethics guidelines to promote responsible AI practices. These guidelines address issues like bias, transparency, fairness, and the impact of AI on society.

  3. Transparency and Accountability: AI governance involves mechanisms to ensure transparency in AI systems. This includes making algorithms and decision-making processes understandable and accountable. It also involves mechanisms for auditing and assessing the impact of AI systems.

  4. Safety and Security: Ensuring the safety and security of AI systems is a top priority. This includes regulating autonomous AI systems, setting safety standards, and addressing cybersecurity concerns to prevent AI-related threats and vulnerabilities.

  5. Data Governance: Effective AI governance involves managing data responsibly. This includes data privacy regulations, data sharing frameworks, and data protection measures to safeguard sensitive information used in AI systems.

2. AI regulations for Children in India
AI regulations for children in India, as in many countries, are crucial to protect the rights, privacy, and well-being of minors in the context of AI technologies
ndia does not currently have any specific laws or regulations governing the use of artificial intelligence (AI) with children. However, there are a number of general laws and regulations that apply

Here's an overview of AI regulations for children in India's perspective:

  1. Data Privacy and Protection: India has enacted the Personal Data Protection Bill, which is expected to become law soon. The bill includes provisions for data protection, including the data of children. It requires consent for processing children's data, imposes stricter requirements for sensitive personal data, and mandates the appointment of a Data Protection Officer (DPO) in certain cases.

  2. COPPA-Like Regulations: India may consider adopting regulations similar to the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) in the United States. COPPA places restrictions on the collection, use, and disclosure of personal information from children under the age of 13.

  3. Age Verification: Platforms and services that collect personal data, including AI-driven platforms, should incorporate mechanisms to verify the age of users and ensure that children are not targeted with content or advertisements that are not suitable for their age group.

  4. Parental Consent: Obtaining informed and verifiable parental consent is essential for processing children's data. Regulations should require service providers to seek parental consent before collecting and processing a child's personal information.

  5. Content Filters and Moderation: AI algorithms used for content filtering and moderation should be designed to protect children from harmful content and prevent exposure to age-inappropriate material. The Indian government may require online platforms to implement such safeguards.

  6. Education and Awareness: Regulations should encourage educational initiatives to promote digital literacy and responsible AI use among children and parents. Schools and educational institutions should play a role in this effort.

  7. AI in Education: As AI is increasingly used in educational technology, regulations should ensure that educational AI systems adhere to strict privacy and security standards. These systems should be transparent about data collection and usage.

  8. Data Retention Limits: Regulations should establish limits on the retention of children's data, ensuring that it is not stored longer than necessary. Data should be securely deleted when no longer needed.

  9. Algorithmic Bias: Regulations should require transparency in AI algorithms used in children's services and ensure that these algorithms are regularly audited for potential biases that may adversely affect children.

  10. Complaint Mechanisms: Children and their parents should have access to mechanisms for reporting violations of their rights and privacy, and regulators should have the authority to investigate and take action against entities that do not comply with regulations.

3. International Practices of regulating AI for Children
International practices for regulating AI for children involve a combination of legal frameworks, industry standards, and ethical guidelines aimed at safeguarding children's rights, privacy, and well-being in the context of artificial intelligence.

There are a number of international practices of regulating AI for children. Some of the key examples include:

  • The European Union (EU): The EU is in the process of developing a comprehensive AI Act, which is expected to include provisions for the protection of children. The draft AI Act proposes a risk-based approach to regulation, with stricter rules for high-risk AI systems. The EU is also developing a set of ethical guidelines for the development and use of AI.
  • The United Kingdom (UK): The UK government has published a white paper on AI, which sets out its vision for the responsible development and use of AI. The white paper includes a number of proposals for regulating AI, including proposals to protect children. For example, the white paper proposes requiring AI developers to conduct risk assessments to identify and mitigate any potential risks to children.
  • The United States (US): The US does not have any comprehensive federal legislation on AI regulation. However, a number of states have passed their own laws on AI regulation. For example, California has passed a law that requires companies to disclose how they collect and use personal data, including the data of children.
  • China: China has published a number of guidelines and policies on AI regulation. In 2021, China published a set of ethical guidelines for the development and use of AI. The guidelines include provisions to protect children, such as prohibiting the use of AI to manipulate or exploit children
 
4. Way forward
In addition to these laws, there are also a number of self-regulatory guidelines that have been developed by the industry. For example, the Internet and Mobile Association of India (IAMAI) has developed a set of guidelines for the responsible use of AI in the online space. These guidelines include provisions to protect children from online harm.
 
 
 
Practice Mains Questions
 
1.Explain the significance of India's Data Protection Bill in the context of AI regulation. How does it address data privacy concerns related to AI applications?
2.The development of ethical AI systems is a global concern. Explain the importance of international cooperation and standards in governing the ethical use of AI technologies.
3.The ethical use of AI in decision-making processes is a growing concern. Discuss the need for regulatory oversight and transparency in algorithmic decision systems

Share to Social