A verdict that hampers international law obligations
- The Most-favored nation (MFN) treatment is a fundamental principle of global trade and a cornerstone of the World Trade Organization (WTO).
- It stipulates that WTO members must extend the same treatment to all other members, regardless of their individual relationships. In other words, if a country grants a particular concession to one trading partner, it must automatically extend the same concession to all other members.
- The MFN principle promotes fairness and predictability in international trade, ensuring that all WTO members have a level playing field and that no country can gain an unfair advantage by giving preferential treatment to specific trading partners. This fosters a more stable and predictable trading environment, which benefits businesses and consumers worldwide.
- There are a few exceptions to the MFN principle. For instance, countries are permitted to form free trade agreements with each other, allowing preferential treatment for goods and services from partner countries.
- However, these agreements must be notified to the WTO and must not violate the MFN principle in a discriminatory manner.
- The MFN principle is a crucial element of the WTO's framework for promoting free trade and economic development. It has played a significant role in reducing tariffs and other trade barriers, contributing to a more open and competitive global marketplace.
DTAAs typically address three main issues:
-
Allocation of taxing rights: DTAAs specify which country has the right to tax a particular type of income. This can be based on the country where the income is earned, the country where the taxpayer is resident, or a combination of both.
-
Credit for foreign taxes: If a taxpayer is taxed on income in one country, the other country may provide a credit for the amount of tax already paid. This ensures that taxpayers do not pay more than they owe in total.
-
Prevention of double taxation: DTAAs may also include provisions to prevent double taxation in specific situations. For example, they may exempt certain types of income from taxation altogether.
-
United States-China Income Tax Treaty: This treaty was signed in 1984 and came into force in 1987. It covers a wide range of income, including business profits, dividends, interest, royalties, and capital gains.
-
United Kingdom-India Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA): This treaty was signed in 1993 and came into force in 1994. It covers a wide range of income, including business profits, dividends, interest, royalties, and capital gains.
-
Australia-United States Double Taxation Convention: This treaty was signed in 1953 and came into force in 1955. It covers a wide range of income, including business profits, dividends, interest, royalties, and capital gains.
Established in 1961, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) is an intergovernmental economic organization with 38 member countries dedicated to fostering economic advancement and global trade. It serves as a platform for member nations, which uphold democracy and market economies, to share policy experiences, seek solutions to common challenges, identify best practices, and coordinate domestic and international policies.
The OECD's responsibilities encompass a wide range of areas, including:
-
Economic Analysis and Forecasting: The OECD generates a comprehensive array of economic data and analysis, including the annual OECD Economic Outlook. Governments, businesses, and other organizations rely on this analysis to make informed economic policy decisions.
-
Policy Advice: The OECD provides expert policy guidance to governments on a broad spectrum of issues, encompassing taxation, education, healthcare, and the environment.
-
Standard-Setting: The OECD establishes international standards for a variety of domains, including accounting, auditing, and trade.
-
International Cooperation: The OECD promotes global cooperation on a wide range of issues, such as climate change, tax evasion, and corruption.
The OECD stands as a valuable resource for governments, businesses, and other organizations worldwide. Its endeavors contribute to advancing economic growth, social well-being, and sustainable development.
4. Double taxation avoidance agreements (DTAAs) and the Income Tax Act
- Double taxation avoidance agreements (DTAAs) and the Income Tax Act collaborate to prevent dual taxation of income for individuals and businesses operating in several jurisdictions.
- DTAAs are international treaties between two countries aimed at eliminating or reducing dual taxation of income earned in one country by residents of the other country. They typically encompass a broad spectrum of income sources, including business profits, dividends, interest, royalties, and capital gains.
- DTAAs achieve their goals by assigning taxing rights to one country or the other, or by providing a credit for taxes paid overseas.
- For instance, if a U.S. resident generates income from a company in Canada, the DTAA between the United States and Canada may specify that Canada has the primary right to tax that income. However, the United States may still allow a deduction for taxes paid to Canada so that the U.S. resident doesn't pay more taxes in total.
- The Income Tax Act is India's primary legislation governing the levy and collection of income tax.
- It applies to all income generated in India, regardless of the taxpayer's residency status. The Act also encompasses income earned by Indian residents from sources outside of India, but only to the extent that the income is not exempt under a DTAA.
- DTAAs supersede domestic tax laws, including the Income Tax Act. This means that if there is a conflict between a DTAA and the Income Tax Act, the DTAA takes precedence.
- For instance, if the Income Tax Act specifies that a specific type of income is taxable in India, but the DTAA between India and another country exempts that type of income from taxation, the DTAA prevails and the income will not be taxable in India.
5. Way forward
DTAAs and the Income Tax Act share a complementary role in preventing double taxation and promoting cross-border investment and trade. DTAAs provide a framework for international cooperation on tax issues, while the Income Tax Act establishes the domestic tax rules that apply to both residents and non-residents of India.
|
Practice Mains Questions 1.Discuss the objectives of double taxation avoidance agreements (DTAAs) and explain how they achieve these objectives 2.Examine the role of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) in developing international tax standards, including DTAAs 3.Examine the role of DTAAs in promoting cross-border investment and trade. Analyse the relationship between DTAAs and domestic tax laws, such as the Income Tax Act |
