PAY COMMISSION
1. Context
The Central government has constituted the 8th Central Pay Commission (CPC) with retired Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai as the Chairperson. It also consists of Professor Pulak Ghosh, faculty at IIM Bangalore, as a part-time member and Pankaj Jain IAS, Secretary to the government of India, as member-secretary. It will submit its report within 18 months.
2. What is the Pay Commission?
- In India, Pay Commissions are constituted through an executive order following a decision by the Cabinet. Their primary function is to examine various aspects related to the pay structure, retirement benefits, and service conditions of Central Government employees, including members of the armed forces, and to suggest appropriate revisions wherever necessary. The establishment of the first Pay Commission dates back to the year 1946
- A Pay Commission is an official body appointed by the Government of India to review and recommend changes to the salary structure, allowances, and pension benefits of Central Government employees, including defence personnel.
- Its main purpose is to ensure that government employees are fairly compensated in line with the changing economic conditions of the country and the rising cost of living.
- The idea of a Pay Commission originated soon after independence. The First Pay Commission was established in 1946, even before India became fully independent.
- Since then, the government has set up a new Pay Commission roughly every ten years to revise the pay structure in keeping with inflation, fiscal capacity, and evolving economic realities.
- So far, seven Pay Commissions have been constituted. The most recent one, the Seventh Pay Commission, was headed by Justice A.K. Mathur and submitted its report in 2015, which was implemented in 2016.
- Each Pay Commission is tasked with examining the existing pay scales of government employees and making recommendations to rationalize them. It studies the disparities between different levels of employees, the balance between civilian and defence personnel salaries, and also the comparison between government and private sector pay levels.
- The Commission’s recommendations aim to promote equity, efficiency, and satisfaction among employees, while ensuring that the government's financial burden remains sustainable.
- The impact of Pay Commissions is significant. Their recommendations affect the income of around 47 lakh serving employees and over 50 lakh pensioners, which also has a multiplier effect on state governments and the economy as a whole.
- Implementation of Pay Commission recommendations often leads to increased consumer spending, but it can also put pressure on government finances due to the rise in salary and pension expenditure
3. What are its terms of reference (TOR)?
- The Terms of Reference (ToR) for each Pay Commission are approved by the Union Cabinet. In the case of the 8th Central Pay Commission (CPC), its ToR directs the body to take into account several key factors while framing its recommendations.
- These include the overall economic situation of the country and the need to maintain fiscal discipline, the requirement to allocate sufficient funds for developmental and welfare initiatives, the financial burden posed by non-contributory pension schemes, and the likely effect of its recommendations on the finances of State governments, which often follow the CPC’s suggestions.
- Additionally, the Commission is expected to assess the existing pay and working conditions in Central public sector undertakings as well as in the private sector to ensure a balanced and realistic approach
4. Global Practices on the Pay Commission
- Across the world, until the 1970s, public sector pay structures were primarily designed to ensure equity by aligning government salaries with those in comparable private sector roles. During the 1980s, however, the focus shifted from equity to efficiency, emphasizing productivity and optimal resource use.
- From the 1990s onward, compensation systems began to integrate performance-based pay and incentives, while also considering the government’s financial capacity. Today, public sector remuneration models are evolving further to attract and retain skilled and competent individuals, all while keeping overall expenditure under control.
- According to international benchmarks, a fair public sector compensation framework should be guided by a clear pay philosophy and should ensure the ability to attract capable talent, maintain fairness within the system (internal equity), remain competitive with the external job market, and provide transparency in structure and rationale.
- In the Indian context, although internal equity receives considerable emphasis, pay competitiveness with the private sector—particularly for senior-level positions—continues to lag behind.
- Interestingly, comparative data from other major democracies reveal that, contrary to the popular belief that India’s public sector is oversized, inefficient, and overpaid, the country actually fares lower on most indicators of public sector employment and wage levels when compared with other large democratic nations
5. Way Forward
Several important elements within the Terms of Reference (ToR) of the Pay Commission merit closer examination. To begin with, the ToR directs the Commission to compare public sector pay structures with those in the private sector—a task that previous Pay Commissions have also undertaken. It has consistently been observed that while entry-level positions in government service tend to offer higher salaries than comparable roles in the private sector, the situation reverses at senior levels and for specialized positions. In the Seventh Pay Commission, the compression ratio—which measures the difference between the lowest and highest salaries in the Central government—was set at 1:12.5. Though government jobs offer various privileges, perks, and the assurance of job security that partly compensate for lower pay at senior levels, it may now be necessary to reconsider this structure, especially for top and expert-level roles, to ensure the government can attract and retain skilled professionals.
Another aspect worth noting is that the ToR does not explicitly address non-monetary factors such as professional development opportunities, training, workplace flexibility, or health and well-being initiatives. It is anticipated that the Pay Commission will take these qualitative factors into account in its final recommendations, recognizing their growing importance in shaping an effective and motivated public workforce
|
For Prelims: Pay Commission, Finance Commission, Article 280, Fiscal Consolidation, Fiscal Federalism, and Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) mechanism.
For Mains: 1. Discuss the Role and Challenges of the Finance Commission in Promoting Fiscal Federalism and Ensuring Equitable Resource Distribution in India. (250 words).
|
Previous year Question1. With reference to the Finance Commission of India, which of the following statements is correct? (UPSC 2011)
A. It encourages the inflow of foreign capital for infrastructure development.
B. It facilitates the proper distribution of finances among the Public Sector Undertaking.
C. It ensures transparency in financial administration.
D. None of the statements (a), (b), and (c) given above is correct in this context.
Answer: D
2. With reference to the Fourteenth Finance Commission, which of the following statements is/are correct? (UPSC 2015)
1. It has increased the share of States in the central divisible pool from 32 percent to 42 percent.
2. It has made recommendations concerning sector-specific grants.
Select the correct answer using the code given below.
A. 1 only
B. 2 only
C. Both 1 and 2
D. Neither 1 nor 2
Answer: A
3. Which of the following is/are among the noticeable features of the recommendations of the Thirteenth Finance Commission? (UPSC 2012)
1. A design for the Goods and Services Tax, and a compensation package linked to adherence to the proposed design.
2. A design for the creation of lakhs of jobs in the next ten years in consonance with India's demographic dividend.
3. Devolution of a specified share of central taxes to local bodies as grants
Select the correct answer using the codes given below:
A. 1 only
B. 2 and 3 only
C. 1 and 3 only
D. 1, 2 and 3
Answer: C
|
Source: The Hindu
