APP Users: If unable to download, please re-install our APP.
Only logged in User can create notes
Only logged in User can create notes

General Studies 2 >> International Relations

audio may take few seconds to load

CHINA'S STANDARDISATION

CHINA'S STANDARDISATION

 

1. Context

On April 2, 2023, the Chinese government announced it would “standardize” the names of 11 places in Arunachal Pradesh. The Ministry of Civil Affairs in Beijing published a list of 11 places along with a map showing the Indian State of Arunachal Pradesh as a part of China’s Tibet Autonomous Region.

2. What are the places on the list?

  • The Chinese Ministry of Civil Affairs notification announced 11 “place names for public use”, in Mandarin, Tibetan, and English (pinyin transliteration of the Chinese names).
  • These include five mountain peaks, two more populated areas, two land areas, and two rivers.
  • All of the 11 sites are on Indian territory, and the southernmost is close to Itanagar.
  • The Chinese government referred to the location of the sites as “Zangnan”, or “south Tibet”, which is how it refers to Arunachal Pradesh.

3. Why is China giving names to places that are in India?

  • China claims some 90,000 sq km of Arunachal Pradesh as its territory.
  • It calls the area “Zangnan” in the Chinese language and makes repeated references to “South Tibet”.
  • Chinese maps show Arunachal Pradesh as part of China, and sometimes parenthetically refer to it as “so-called Arunachal Pradesh”.
  • China makes periodic efforts to underline this unilateral claim to Indian territory.
  • Giving Chinese names to places in Arunachal Pradesh is part of that effort. 

4. How many times China has renamed places in Arunachal Pradesh?

  • This is the third time China is issuing names for places in Arunachal Pradesh, a gesture seen as provocative by India and one that has coincided with periods of strains in relations.
  • In 2017, the first list of “standardized” names was issued for six places in Arunachal, which was then seen as a retaliatory move after the Tibetan spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama, visited the State.
  • The second such list was issued in December 2021, more than a year into the crisis sparked by China’s multiple transgressions across the Line of Actual Control (LAC) starting in April 2020.
  • The second list coincided with a new border law passed by the Chinese government that called for various Chinese civilian and military agencies to take steps to “safeguard” Chinese territory, including through such administrative measures.
  • The second list had 15 places, including eight towns, four mountains, two rivers, and the Sela mountain pass. 

5. What is McMahon Line?

  • The disputed boundary in the Eastern Sector of the India-China border is over the McMahon Line.
  • Representatives of China, India, and Tibet in 1913-14 met in Shimla to settle the boundary between Tibet and India, and Tibet and China.
  • During the Shimla conference, Sir Henry McMahon, the then foreign secretary of British India, drew up the 550-mile (890 km) McMahon Line as the border between British India and Tibet.
Image Source: India Today

6. The dispute between India and China's  Eastern sector

  • The McMohan line moved British control substantially northwards. This agreement ceded Tawang and other areas to the imperial British Empire.
  • Though the Chinese representatives at the meeting initiated the agreement, they subsequently refused to accept it.
  • Subsequently, the Chinese government stated that it does not recognize the "Illegal McMohan Line.
  • China accuses India of occupying areas in Arunachal, which it calls part of Southern Tibet.
  • China claims territory to the south of the McMohan Line, lying in Arunachal Pradesh.
  • China also bases its claims on the historical ties that have existed between the monasteries in Tawang and Lhasa.

7. What is behind China's move?

  • As with the two previous cases, India rejected the Chinese announcement. Arunachal Pradesh is, has been, and will always be an integral and inalienable part of India.
  • More broadly, the moves from Beijing point to a hardening of its stand on territorial disputes, which are now seen less as matters to be resolved diplomatically and bilaterally but as questions of China's sovereignty.
  • Besides the renaming, the new border law as well as the new regulations from the State Council all underscore how under current leader Xi Jinping, the protection of national sovereignty and the territory has been mandated under various laws.
  • This has also driven more activity along the borders from local­level authorities, such as stepped-up programs to build new civilian settlements (including some that have come up
    on territory disputed by both Bhutan and India) as well as other border infrastructure.

8. What does China seek to gain from making these claims? 

  • It is a part of the Chinese strategy to assert its territorial claims over Indian territory.
  • As a part of this strategy, China routinely issues statements of outrage whenever an Indian dignitary visits Arunachal Pradesh.
  • It did so when the then Vice President Venkaiah Naidu went there to address the state Assembly in October 2021.
  • The first batch of renaming in 2017 had come days after the Dalai Lama visited Arunachal Pradesh.
  • Also, Chinese officials claim that standardization was necessary since all names used in southern Tibet were inherited through word-of-mouth for generations by minority ethnic groups.
  • Hence, these names reflect that China's proposal on the sovereignty claim of the region has a prominent historical, cultural, administrative, and jurisdictional.
  • Laying aggressive claims to territories based on alleged historical injustices done to China is part of Beijing's foreign policy playbook. The Claim on Taiwan is one such example.
  • Also, consistent efforts are being made by China to change the facts on the ground in several disputed islands in the south china sea.
For Prelims: Zangnan, or south Tibet, Arunachal Pradesh, Line of Actual Control (LAC), McMahon Line, and Bhutan.
For Mains: 1. In the wake of the recent renaming of some places in Arunachal Pradesh by China, India needs a comprehensive strategy to solve the border issues with the neighboring country". Discuss. (250 words).
 

Previous year Question

1. What is/are the recent tension between India and China highlighted in the newspaper? (TNPSC Group 1 2015)
A. China's proposed dam on Brahmaputra
B. PM's visit to Arunachal Pradesh
C. China recently tried to block an ADB loan
D. All of these
Answer: D
Source: The Hindu

Share to Social